Why Don't We Do Things That Just Make Sense?

📅 November 21, 2026 ✍️ QuestionClass
calm the mind

How competing incentives, cognitive biases, and collective action problems prevent us from doing what seems obvious.

We don't always do things that make sense because recognizing a better outcome and having sufficient reason to pursue it are two different things. Our decisions are shaped by personal incentives, immediate costs, limited information, and competing priorities. What makes sense from one perspective does not necessarily make sense from another.

This explains why organizations maintain inefficient processes, governments struggle to implement seemingly obvious improvements, and individuals repeatedly make choices contrary to their long-term interests.

The problem is not always a failure of intelligence. Sometimes, it is a failure of alignment.

What Makes Sense Depends on Where You Stand

Imagine a company discovers that automating an administrative process would save thousands of hours annually.

Everyone recognizes the potential savings. Yet the department responsible for implementing automation would lose headcount, its manager would oversee a smaller team, and employees would face uncertainty about their jobs.

PerspectiveWhat makes sense
Executive sponsorReduce operating costs
Department managerPreserve resources and authority
EmployeeProtect job security
IT teamMinimize technical and security risks
Finance teamLimit upfront expenditure

Nobody needs to misunderstand the opportunity for it to remain unrealized. Each participant can understand the situation while pursuing a different objective.

The disagreement is not necessarily about what works. It is about what matters.

We Follow Incentives, Not Just Logic

In his 1975 paper, On the Folly of Rewarding A, While Hoping for B, management scholar Steven Kerr examined how organizations reward behaviors other than the ones they claim to want.

A company encourages innovation but penalizes failed experiments. A school promotes learning but rewards test performance. A customer service department emphasizes customer satisfaction but evaluates employees on how quickly they end calls.

In each case, people receive two sets of instructions: what they are told matters and what actually determines their success.

Explaining the benefits of a sensible decision accomplishes little when the obstacle is the personal consequence of acting on it.

We Don't All See the Same Problem

In their 1958 study, Selective Perception: A Note on the Departmental Identifications of Executives, DeWitt Dearborn and Herbert Simon presented executives with the same business case. The problems executives identified varied according to their departmental affiliations.

Their professional experiences influenced what they noticed and considered important.

This illustrates a broader concept known as bounded rationality. People make decisions within the limits of their information, experience, time, and cognitive capacity.

What appears to be common sense is frequently the product of uncommon experience.

We Value Today More Than Tomorrow

We know that exercising regularly, saving money, and getting sufficient sleep benefit us. Yet knowing these things does not guarantee that we do them.

Behavioral economists call the tendency to give disproportionate weight to immediate rewards present bias. Economist David Laibson explored this inconsistency in his 1997 paper, Golden Eggs and Hyperbolic Discounting.

Consider someone who plans to exercise tomorrow morning. Tonight, the future benefits of exercise outweigh the anticipated inconvenience. When the alarm sounds, however, another thirty minutes of sleep becomes immediately rewarding.

The information hasn't changed. The proximity of the reward has.

Commitment devices, such as automatic savings deductions or arranging to exercise with a friend, help align our immediate behavior with our longer-term intentions.

The Existing Decision Has an Advantage

In their 1988 study, Status Quo Bias in Decision Making, William Samuelson and Richard Zeckhauser demonstrated that people have a tendency to favor existing arrangements.

Consider an organization using outdated software. Keeping it requires no migration plan or immediate disruption. Replacing it requires someone to assume responsibility for the transition.

The existing decision does not face the same burden of justification as the proposed decision.

Sometimes maintaining the status quo is reasonable. Switching involves genuine costs, including training, downtime, and implementation risks. The bias emerges when we give existing arrangements preferential treatment beyond what those costs justify.

Would we choose our current arrangement again if we were starting from scratch?

Agreement Does Not Guarantee Action

In his 1965 book, The Logic of Collective Action, economist Mancur Olson challenged the assumption that people with shared interests will naturally act together to advance them.

Imagine ten neighboring businesses that would benefit from improving their street. Better lighting, landscaping, and signage would make the area more attractive to customers.

Every business supports the idea, but each has an incentive to let the others absorb the expense.

This is known as the free-rider problem. Individually rational decisions can produce a collectively undesirable outcome.

The solution is not another presentation explaining why street improvements are beneficial. It is an arrangement that distributes costs and establishes shared commitments.

Diagnosing Why Something Sensible Isn't Happening

Different obstacles require different solutions.

What's preventing action?What needs to change?
Competing objectivesEstablish shared priorities
Misaligned incentivesChange rewards and consequences
Selective perceptionIntroduce other perspectives
Present biasEstablish commitment devices
Status quo biasReevaluate existing arrangements
Implementation costsReduce the cost of transition
Collective action problemsEstablish shared commitments

The mistake is treating every failure to act as a failure to understand. More evidence will not necessarily resolve an incentive problem, just as better incentives will not necessarily resolve a technical constraint.

🧬 QuestionStrings to Practice

From obvious to actionable

Use this sequence when something seems sensible but nobody is doing it.

What makes this action sensible? → Who benefits and who bears the cost? → What makes the existing behavior preferable? → What would need to change to make the better outcome achievable?

Understanding why something makes sense is only half the problem. Understanding why it isn't happening is the other half.

The next time you find yourself wondering why nobody is doing something that seems obvious, consider a different question:

What makes not doing it make sense?

Explore another question every day at QuestionClass.

← Home

You just thought more carefully than most people do all day.

One question like this, every morning. Free.

Start My Daily Practice →

No password needed  ·  Takes 30 seconds


Discover more from QuestionClass

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.