Why do people work in coffee shops?

The psychology of working alone, together.
People work in coffee shops because they offer environmental stimulation, social presence, personal autonomy, and separation from domestic distractions. They allow people to work independently without being isolated, introduce structure without imposing a schedule, and provide activity without requiring participation.
Buying a coffee also buys temporary access to a different set of working conditions.
The reinvention of the third place
Sociologist Ray Oldenburg popularized the concept of the third place, an informal gathering space outside the home (the first place) and workplace (the second place).
Conversation was central to Oldenburg's concept. Third places existed to bring people together, not to provide individual workstations.
Today's laptop-wielding customers reverse that relationship. They seek social environments to engage in solitary activities.
In his 2012 study, The Changing Nature of the Coffee Shop in the 21st Century: How Productivity is Supplanting Social Interaction, Benjamin R. Garner found that most participants visited coffee shops for work rather than conversation or forming friendships. His findings suggest that customers enjoy a sense of collective solidarity from pursuing similar activities alongside others, even without speaking to them.
Researchers Laetitia Mimoun and Adèle Gruen explored this evolution in their 2021 study, Customer Work Practices and the Productive Third Place. They identified a category of establishments that deliberately accommodate independent workers while remaining open to customers seeking social experiences.
This creates a paradox. People visit coffee shops to experience a social atmosphere while limiting their contribution to the conversations that traditionally create it.
How background noise influences creativity
In their 2012 study, Is Noise Always Bad? Exploring the Effects of Ambient Noise on Creative Cognition, Ravi Mehta, Rui Zhu, and Amar Cheema conducted five experiments examining noise and creative performance.
Moderate background noise at 70 decibels improved creative-task performance compared with 50 decibels. Higher noise levels of 85 decibels impaired it.
The researchers found that moderate noise increased mental processing difficulty, encouraging more abstract thinking and supporting creativity.
How does that compare with an actual coffee shop?
The 2016 study Knowledge, Attitudes, Behaviors and Noise Exposure of Baristas reports café sound measurements ranging from 66.5 to 81.9 dBA, drawing on Australia's National Acoustic Laboratories noise database.
These measurements occupy a similar range to the experimental noise levels, although dBA adjusts sound measurements for human hearing sensitivity and is not directly interchangeable with unweighted dB.
The type of noise also matters. Psychologists call the disruption caused by unrelated background speech the irrelevant speech effect. A 2019 eye-tracking study by Martin Vasilev and colleagues found that intelligible background speech caused readers to revisit words more frequently, disrupting the reading process.
Seventy decibels of background noise is not necessarily equivalent to seventy decibels of neighboring conversation.
Working alone, together
Social facilitation describes how the presence of other people influences individual performance.
In their 1983 meta-analysis of 241 studies, psychologists Charles Bond and Linda Titus found that the presence of others generally increased the speed of simple tasks but reduced the speed and accuracy of complex ones. The overall effects were small.
Mimoun and Gruen's research illustrates a related motivational benefit. One participant, Alex, described feeling guilty about taking a break to watch television when surrounded by other people working.
Consider a hypothetical freelance writer who struggles to begin an article at home. Household responsibilities and entertainment compete for attention. Moving to a coffee shop removes those distractions and establishes a dedicated working session.
Yet drafting an article is complex work. Bond and Titus's findings suggest that the presence of others could make aspects of writing more difficult, even as the environment encourages the writer to get started.
Structure without surrendering autonomy
Independent workers often need to create their own working routines.
Coffee shops offer a way to establish structure while retaining control over those routines.
Psychologists Richard Ryan and Edward Deci identified autonomy as one of three basic psychological needs in their 2000 paper on self-determination theory, alongside competence and relatedness. Their research connects the satisfaction of these needs with motivation and well-being.
The theory offers a framework for understanding the appeal of coffee shops. Workers with location flexibility can choose when to arrive, how long to stay, and which tasks to tackle. They can also experience a degree of social connection without committing to interaction.
Ordering coffee marks the beginning of a working session. Leaving provides an endpoint. The worker determines what happens between those moments.
The limits of a shared environment
The qualities that attract independent workers can conflict with what other customers want.
Mimoun and Gruen documented competition for seating during busy periods and disagreements over noise and atmosphere. Some customers seeking conversation found themselves surrounded by people working silently, while workers sought conditions conducive to concentration.
The coffee shop's appeal depends partly on how these competing needs coexist. Enough activity creates a sense of companionship. Too much activity introduces interruptions. Too little changes the social atmosphere that attracted people in the first place.
For independent workers, the practical lesson is to choose an environment according to the demands of the task.
A coffee shop that solves your motivation problem might not solve your concentration problem.
Before deciding where to work, ask yourself which problem you actually need to solve.
Stay curious. Explore another Question-a-Day at QuestionClass.
You just thought more carefully than most people do all day.
One question like this, every morning. Free.
Start My Daily Practice →No password needed · Takes 30 seconds
Discover more from QuestionClass
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.